Sushi children defy Sunni-Shia divide

Dr. Mike Ghouse   June 24, 2016   Comments Off on Sushi children defy Sunni-Shia divide

How sad it its, the Shia-Sunni was not an issue 30 years ago, all across the world. The divisive forces have gains to be had by pitting one against the other. I hope people resume their lives, the life of pluralism.

Mike Ghouse
Center for Pluralism

courtesy of BBC
By Nesrine Kamal
18 June 2016

Comedian Nasser al-Qasabi (2)
Saudi actor and comedian Nasser al-Qasabi

It is a story line of an episode of a satirical Saudi TV series which has sparked wide debate on social media.

The plot: two babies switched at birth by mistake in a Saudi hospital and raised by two radical families – one Sunni, the other Shia.

Years later, the hospital discovers the error and each son, now a young man, goes to live with his real family.

When the fathers discover their sons were raised by a family from an “opposing” sect, they desperately attempt to change their off springs’ religious perceptions, trying to convince them that they have not been following the “right doctrine”.

The series, Selfie, stars popular but controversial satirist Nasser al-Qasabi.

On Twitter, the comedian asked his audience to “fasten seat belts” before the episode was shown. Afterwards it was praised by both Sunni and Shia viewers.

Although the Sunni and Shia branches of Islam share fundamental beliefs, they differ in religious practices, rituals and organisation. The intensity of the divide differs from one Islamic country to another.

The majority of Muslims in the world are Sunnis. Shia, who make up roughly 10% of the Muslim population, are a majority in Iraq, Iran and Bahrain.

They also constitute large sections of the population in Syria, Lebanon and Saudi Arabia, while they are a minority in Egypt and Jordan.

‘Sushi’ children

Sunni-Shia marriages illustrate the sensitivity of the sectarian divide in some countries.
While such unions are common in countries with large Shia populations like Iraq and Lebanon, they are rare in Egypt and Sunni-ruled Saudi Arabia.

The subject of “Sushi” children – a reference to the offspring of Sunni-Shia marriages – remains a sensitive topic for many.

Saudis attend the Janadriyah festival of Heritage and Culture held in the Saudi village of Al-Thamama, 50 kilometres north of the capital Riyadh Image copyright

Sunni-Shia marriages are rare in Sunni-ruled Saudi Arabia

Arij Umran (not her real name) spoke to the BBC about her experience as a young Saudi woman who was born to a Sunni father and a Shia mother.

“My parents met and got married in Iraq 40 years ago. Sunni-Shia marriages were not such a big deal back then. However, when they returned to Saudi Arabia, they started facing some difficulties.”

Arij says that as a child, she had to keep her mother’s doctrine a secret because many friends “stopped talking to her” when they found out her mother was a Shia.

She says her parents were open-minded and supportive of her choices. When she asked which doctrine she should follow, they said: “It is your duty to find out. You need to read, learn and tell us what you have decided”.

BBC Monitoring journalist Mina al-Lami, who was born in Iraq into a Sunni-Shia inter-marriage, says that having a parent from each sect was and continues to be common in Iraq, especially in mixed areas like the capital Baghdad.

“Growing up there, I didn’t even know there were two different sects until my early 20s,” Mina says. While Sunni-Shia marriages have dropped in Iraq after 2003 given sectarian tensions, they are still not unusual, she adds.

Still showing two girls from Hoda El Soudani’s film ‘Why can’t I be a Sushi?’
Hoda El Soudani’s film ‘Why can’t I be a Sushi?’ features sisters Nimah (left) and Sofia
The issue was also tackled by the British-Iraqi filmmaker Hoda El Soudani in her documentary “Why Can’t I be a Sushi?”.
The filmmaker told the BBC: “My main intention was to objectively address as many key issues as possible that one sect may have towards the other sect, and then break down the misconceptions so that some kind of bridge could be built once they realise they have so much in common”.
Still from Hoda El Soudani’s film ‘Why can’t I be a Sushi?’Image copyright
Image caption
The sisters met Islamic scholars on their travels

She says she was motivated to address this sensitive subject after “seeing what is happening elsewhere: in Saudi Arabia, in Yemen, Iran, Iraq…”.

“The point is not to ask why there are differences of opinion, but rather why these differences have led to violence and animosity. To me, the conflict seems to be more political than religious, although it may be hiding behind the religious language.”

Still from Hoda El Soudani’s film ‘Why can’t I be a Sushi?’

“People may say the film is painting a romanticised picture of Sunnis and Shia uniting, but I would say if it existed once, then it can exist again. I’m sure we can be less arrogant and more accepting of the other sect.”

“People needed to be reminded to go back to their roots and embrace the simplicity of just being a Muslim regardless of which sect one follows,” Hoda adds.

BBC Monitoring reports and analyses news from TV, radio, web and print media around the world. You can follow BBC Monitoring on Twitter and Facebook.

Images by Houda and Getty Images
shia-sunni-islamic-scholars Sunni-Shia