The Patriotism of Hate Between Nuclear Rivals

Dr. Mike Ghouse   April 16, 2019   Comments Off on The Patriotism of Hate Between Nuclear Rivals

We the old farts will die one day or the other,  and I hope we don’t poison our children with hate for the other. They don’t need to live with anxieties and stupid slogans – does anyone teach their kids to find freedom, mukti, moksha or… they make their children be born again and again until they are free from hate, anger, ill-will, etc.  Hate does not put food on the table, as Indians and Pakistanis, we should be trained to think, act and talk peace and live in peace and live freely.

by Tarunjit Singh Butalia
Courtesy – The Interfaith Observer

India-Pakistan flag lowering ceremony at Wagah border, India in March 2019 – Photo: Tarunjit Singh Butalia

India-Pakistan flag lowering ceremony at Wagah border, India in March 2019 – Photo: Tarunjit Singh Butalia

I just returned from a visit to South Asia. Right before my visit, the tensions between nuclear rivals India and Pakistan were at an all-time high, with each side portraying the other as evil and the enemy of its people.

During my visit, I had the opportunity to visit the India-Pakistan border in Punjab, India at Wagah, to watch the evening ceremony of the lowering flags by both countries at the border crossing. I expected it to be a solemn event – but boy was I in for a surprise! It was a full-fledged Bollywood style extravaganza of loudspeakers and live patriotism, full-blast, being led on both sides by the border protection forces of each country. 

Every call from Pakistanis sitting on the other side of the fence of “Pakistan Zindabad” (long live Pakistan) had to be answered with an even louder “Bharat Mata Ki Jai” (glory to Mother India) from the Indian side – back and forth, equally dramatic. In between groups of individuals would scream obscenities at those sitting across the border, with others on the same side cheering on proudly and laughing. Each side had to drown out the voices of the other. The armed forces personnel leading the ceremony on both sides interacted with pre-rehearsed visibly confrontational postures and screams, as if they were ready to attack the other side. No wonder the crowd was emboldened into a passion of hateful patriotism.

Photo:    Wikimedia

Photo: Wikimedia

As I sat among the frenzied Indian crowd, the person sitting next to me inquired why I was not being a patriotic Indian by joining in the fun. My response had him dumbfounded: “My ancestors lived on the other side for centuries before they migrated to India through these very gates about 70 years ago. My ancestral home still stands on the land on the other side, the same blood flows in us as in the Pakistanis. I am a citizen of USA, so want both countries to live in peace and the land of my ancestors can be healed.” 

His response was a loud announcement that a Pakistani agent was sitting next to him. As a Sikh who wears a turban, I was clearly outed by my neighbor as an alleged Pakistani agent. The chorus around me grew angrier, and I decided to leave the event for my own personal safety. As I shuffled out from the crowd, I heard several people telling me to go to Pakistan so when India drops a nuclear bomb on Pakistan I can enjoy it. As I walked back to the parking lot, I imagined the same treatment being meted out to someone on the other side of the border – go to India and wait till we nuke them.

This was shocking – people are so angry and upset at those on the other side that dropping nuclear bombs on the other side of a man made line of demarcation has become a joke, a way to demonize those on the other side. I have never seen such hateful patriotism in my life, although I have read of the behavior of some Trump supporters who exhibit similar sentiments. I can never forget that my own country – USA – is the only one to have used a nuclear bomb ever in the history of humankind. And this is something that we as Americans still seem to be proud of – utterly disgusting.

While in Delhi before returning to America, I visited a street market for souvenirs for my kids. On the way out, I noticed a museum dedicated to the former President of India Abdul Kalam. I immediately recognized his name, as he is considered to be the pioneer of India’s nuclear arms program. Walking through the museum I noticed that his development of nuclear weapons for India was given special focus. How ironic that the land of Gandhi’s non-violence was now so proud of nuclear weapons.

There is a silver lining. While extremes in both India and Pakistan have support of the government and the religious right, the vast majority on South Asians have a common future. When the wind blows, it does not matter which direction it blows in. We are all in it together.

It is well known that many of the nuclear weapons of India and Pakistan are placed in the South Asian region on Punjab – which is currently divided between the two countries. A nuclear warfare between the two nations would decimate Punjab – the Land of the Five Rivers and its people.

It is time for civic society in South Asia to work together towards a secure common interdependent future based on mutual trust rather than hateful patriotism.

Dr. Tarunjit Singh Butalia is a board trustee of Sikh Council for Interfaith Relations, Parliament of the World’s Religions, and North American Interfaith Network and serves as Special Advisor with Religions for Peace – USA. He has served on board of National Religious Coalition Against Torture and World Sikh Council – America Region. Locally he has worked with Interfaith Association for Central Ohio for over 20 years and currently is Moderator of its Program Committee. He is co-editor of landmark book Religion in Ohio: Profiles of Faith Communities and received the 2016 Luminosa Award for Unity from Focolare Movement.